What Got You Here Won’t Get You There: Reinventing the Association Executive for the Next Era

New way- Improvement and change management concept stock illustration July 29, 2025 By: Chris Vaughan, Ph.D.

These five mindset shifts can help today’s association executive lead effectively in a rapidly changing, disruption-driven world.

Austrian American pioneer of management theory, Peter Drucker, once warned, “The greatest danger in times of turbulence is not the turbulence—it is to act with yesterday’s logic.” That warning feels tailor-made for today’s association executive. The familiar terrain—steady programs, predictable renewals, operational efficiency—has fractured, reshaped by AI disruption, shrinking attention spans, and a new generation of members who define value in entirely new terms. The role of the association executive is evolving. What matters now is whether we're brave enough to lead that change.

To thrive in this new era, association leaders must transform as dramatically as the environment they’re navigating. The executive role must evolve from institutional caretaker to strategic architect. Rather than tinkering at the edges, it calls for rewriting the executive role from the ground up.

What Is a Strategic Architect?

The legacy executive model was built for a different time. It prized continuity, internal efficiency, and institutional knowledge. This approach served associations well for decades, especially in slow-moving environments where incremental change sufficed. But today’s pace of disruption makes stability a liability if it comes at the cost of innovation. Leadership guru Marshall Goldsmith said it best: “What got you here won’t get you there.”

To meet this moment, executives must adopt a new paradigm: the strategic architect. A strategic architect doesn’t just fix what’s broken—they redraw the blueprint. They see the whole system and aren’t afraid to rebuild it midflight. Strategic architects are fluent in the future. They sense what’s coming and reshape their organizations before disruption hits.

Based on our work with hundreds of associations, here are five leadership traits that are redefining the next-generation executive, with a guiding question for each to prompt action.

1. Make Sense When Others See Chaos

In times of accelerating change, leaders must move beyond passive trend-watching and become active students of disruption. It’s beyond staying informed. It’s about synthesizing weak signals from the edges of the industry, understanding the implications of AI, social change, or policy shifts, and helping others see what’s next before it arrives. These leaders create clarity without minimizing complexity.

Ask yourself: What signals are emerging today that most leaders won’t see until it’s too late?

2. Become Part of Their Success Story

They understand that yesterday’s value propositions won’t resonate with tomorrow’s members. These leaders actively redefine value across generations, professions, and markets. They elevate the conversation from benefits to outcomes, positioning the association as a source of transformation, not just for services.

Ask yourself: How would our value proposition change if our next generation of members were to design it?

3. Change the Rules, Not Just the Plays

Rather than optimizing within existing constraints, strategic architects rethink the system itself. They challenge legacy assumptions about how programs, revenue, and membership all work together. They experiment with new business models and are unafraid to sunset what no longer serves them.

A handful of bold associations are flipping the script on revenue: retiring underperforming member programs and investing instead in IP licensing, data monetization, or enterprise partnerships that scale without member volume. Ask yourself: If your business model didn’t exist, would you invent it today?

4. Get That Relationships Make Change Possible

These leaders understand that transformation doesn’t happen in silos or through top-down mandates. They build coalitions of the willing, listen across boundaries, and treat relationships as infrastructure for innovation. They lead by building trust across teams, partners, and stakeholders, and by showing up as collaborators, not commanders.

Ask yourself: Whose trust have we not earned but need to?

5. Turn Learning Into a Strategic Advantage

In a landscape shaped by volatility and reinvention, the most future-ready leaders treat learning not as a professional nicety but as a strategic weapon. They take lessons learned from experiences, conferences, and case studies to create systems that build learning into decision-making, talent development, and innovation. They operationalize foresight and reward calculated risk.

Ask yourself: What are we learning today that will give us an edge tomorrow?

What does this mean in practice?

It means moving from a mindset of “running the institution” to “reinventing our role in members’ success.” It means questioning sacred cows, reorienting the organization toward future-facing strategy, and treating disruption not as a threat, but as an invitation.

The path forward won’t be paved by tradition. It will be charted by those bold enough to redraw the map. The future of your organization depends on the evolution of its leadership. And that begins with you.

Chris Vaughan, Ph.D.

Chris Vaughan, Ph.D., is cofounder and chief strategy officer of Sequence Consulting.